SEO Confusion Reigns: Why Is Your Properly Optimized Site Losing out to Others?

What gets your page up, up, up in the rankings? Depending on how new you are to this whole SEO thing, you probably already have some grasp of the concepts that drive a page up in the SERPs, but it’s always useful to give them another run-down, in order to refresh the info. There are several factors in this respect:

  • Domain-based: These factors have to do with domain authority and user trust, which Google has been relying on to an ever-larger extent, in order to validate sources of information.
  • Page-based: This is just about everything that is contained on the published webpage. These factors go from the granular (targeted keywords and how organic this targeting is), the quality of the content and extent to which it manages to engage the user (think bounce rate, first and foremost), and inbound links to each specific URL – as opposed to inbound link to the site as a whole.
  • Listing-based: This largely has to do with the search snippet that the webmaster optimizes (or not), in order to give the user as clear a picture of what they’re about to click on as possible. If you think the snippet isn’t that important, think again. We’ve seen recent examples where Google decided to improve the ranking of a given page, based on the number of clicks the snippet was getting. In other words, Google does take into account the way users credit various pages – if it sees they trust it, then Google, too, is going to trust it as well.

seo optimization tips

Of course, the issue of being outranked by ‘poorer quality’ websites first became an issue when Panda rolled out. It may not have hit everyone with as much force right from the get-go, but eventually, as the update rolled out, many webmasters felt the sharp drop in rankings and understood they were being penalized for past actions, which, at the time they had used them, were gray hat at best. Since Google isn’t exactly transparent about what it will penalize or not, here is a selection of reasons you may have lost out in the face of other websites, post-Panda:

  • Duplicate content: Google will sanction duplicate content severely, irrespective of whether or not your site is the original source of the content.
  • Comment spam: commenting in order to promote your own URLs is generally frowned upon. You may actually provide insightful commentary, which does contribute to a particular conversation – if there’s a link in it, Google will most likely frown upon it. Consider the weight of authorship as a replacement to this promotional tool. Instead of commenting with your link attached left and right, build a strong social media authorship presence.
  • Syndicated content and article directory submissions: if you’re paying to get content across the web, on your targeted keywords and URLs, Google will not like it. Instead, do some genuine, well-researched, quality guest posting and build connections with other webmasters. You will find that, in time, these relationships are beneficial both ways.

Now, in the wake of Panda and Penguin, many site admins have been left wondering if there’s a way to fix the damage they’ve done in the past, or should simply forget all about SEO and the much-touted ‘if you’re not on the Internet, you don’t exist mind frame’. It’s usually smaller companies that find themselves wondering what to do, but major names such as the UK’s Inter-flora have been previously penalized for what Google saw as underhanded optimization and link-building activities. The takeaway here is that, if you’ve been hit by either Panda or Penguin, you do need to put some more work into your understanding of Google’s algorithms, but, more importantly, its motivation for choosing to rank one site better than the other in the SERPs. Also, aside from investing into good SEO, you need to spread your efforts to social media and other means of generating brand awareness, because, the way things stand at the moment, Google cannot be regarded as a single, wholly dependable avenue for marketing and promotional efforts.

You May Also Like

About the Author: Shameem

I am Shameem, Software Engineer, Web Addicted, Living in Chennai, India.


  1. Good and useful post for the bloggers for better understanding of SEO by you Shameem.

    Yeah, i knew few of these facts already and hope my blog wouldn’t be hit by Panda and Penguin algorithm.

    Am not worrying about page based, duplicate content and comment spam, but I need to take care of my bounce rate as it is a bit high.

    Thanks for presenting an awesome post Shameen.

    1. Hi Nirmala glad to hear that you are aware of some facts hope you will take care of your bounce rate meanwhile i’m Shameem not shameen LoL keep coming 🙂

  2. This is a classical post every blogger or webmaster out there should read about. I have wondered why a site that scraped few lines of my content will out rank me until i read somewhere in moz that there are factors that can cause this and ever since then i have corrected my mistakes and am beginning to see the difference.

    Yes Google algorithm is not easy to completely comprehend but having a good knowledge of it can make the difference. one need to be updated with the latest happening in the blogosphere so as not to be left behind and thats why i like reading from you.

    In this article you have listed quite some important ways to improve ranking like Social media and content syndication. Thanks for sharing such an amazing article, i find it very informative.

    1. Hey Nwosu Desmond glad you like the post and sounds great that you are seeing the difference yes we need to have some aware about google algorithm to be on the line thanks for the comment 🙂

  3. Great post Shameem – question I’ve been asking myself on a retail a website I handle.It goes up and then back down. Like a see-saw. I try not to change up too much often, I refresh old product pages and update blog weekly. I agree with Manthan, SEO can drive you crazy! It’s not for the feeble hearted, you have to keep on trying 🙂

    1. Hi Lisa glad to see you on my blog yes seo needs lots of testing and having an eye on our old pages will make them to reach good ranking on search engine between thanks for your comment

  4. This is insightful information Shameem.Thanks for sharing it.SEO is becoming difficult with all the new algorithm updates.Miss the days when you could rank on top with a decent page and some backlinks.

  5. Interesting piece, Shameem. I’ve be reading all the chatter about all the various SEO struggles and I can’t help but empathize. I don’t personally worry about SEO as my site isn’t reliant upon it but I know that those who are being affected by it, as I see within your comments, can find it to be a huge headache.

    Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts and insights with us. Glad to have found your piece on BizSugar.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.